After co-founding a startup, leading teams at WB Games Boston and Scopely, and now spending my days meeting with founders at Founder Collective, I’ve become convinced that talent density is one of the strongest predictors of success at an early-stage startup.
When your product is still a hypothesis… the team is the company. The quality of the people solving those problems is what determines whether you make it to the other side.
One of the things I admired most during my time at Scopely was how seriously leadership treated hiring. Everyone understood what great looked like and leaders were expected to spend a significant amount of their time and energy recruiting exceptional people.
A few lessons I’ve carried with me:
Maximize talent density
Every hire changes the trajectory of the company for better or worse. Bad quarters are survivable, but bad hires will destroy your startup over time.
Hire builders over brands
Someone working at OpenAI, Meta, or Google doesn’t automatically make them exceptional. What did they actually build? What changed because they were there? Ask for specific examples. Dig into the details and backchannel.
Don’t wait for great candidates to apply
Most of our best hires came from proactively recruiting people who weren’t looking. Many initially told us they weren’t interested. A surprising number eventually joined.
Pay attention to the side quests
Find people who’ve done hard things outside their careers. Folks who started businesses, competed at a high level, mastered a craft, built things on nights/weekends. Those experiences often reveal grit, curiosity, and resilience that don’t show up on a resume.
Founders should own hiring
If an exceptional candidate appears for a critical role, drop what you’re doing and focus on them. In the early years, founders should meet every hire before an offer letter goes out. Few things have higher ROI.
One phrase I’ve started using is: “Talent density creates gravity.”
Great people attract other great people, raise standards, accelerate the business, solve harder problems, and attract better customers, investors, and future teammates. Your org chart is your strategy in human form, don’t delegate it.